SilverSingles vs OurTime: Which Dating Site Wins for Over 50 Singles?

Quick Verdict

Choose SilverSingles if: you want personality-based matching and don’t mind a guided experience.
Choose OurTime if: you want to browse a large pool freely and stay in full control.

Both are legitimate, 50+ focused dating sites – they just work very differently. Here’s the head-to-head.

SilverSingles vs OurTime at a Glance

	SilverSingles	OurTime
Owned by	Spark Networks	Match Group
Matching style	Personality test + daily matches	Free browsing + search
Members	~1M+ (US/UK/CA/AU)	Larger overall pool
Signup time	20-30 min (quiz)	5-10 min
Starting price	~$19.95/month (12 mo)	~$19.96/month (12 mo)
Free version	Test + view matches	Profile + browse
Best for	Guided daters	Independent browsers

How Matching Works

SilverSingles: the algorithm leads

SilverSingles starts with a detailed personality test (about 25 minutes) based on the Big Five model. You then receive 3-7 curated matches per day. You can’t freely browse the whole database – you trust the compatibility engine.

OurTime: you lead

OurTime skips the quiz. You create a profile in minutes, then browse and search the entire member base with filters for distance, interests and more. There’s also a swipe-style “I’m Interested” feature for faster browsing.

User Base

Both sites are strictly 50+, which is the whole point. Practical differences:

• OurTime has the larger total membership in the US, which matters if you live outside a major city
• SilverSingles members skew slightly more educated and relationship-focused
• Gender ratios are balanced on both

If you’re in a rural or suburban area, OurTime’s bigger pool is a real advantage.

Pricing Compared

The 12-month plans are nearly identical:

• SilverSingles: ~$19.95/month
• OurTime: ~$19.96/month

Both get expensive on short-term plans, and both auto-renew by default. Note: prices and promotions change often, so always check the official sites before subscribing.

Ease of Use

• SilverSingles: polished, modern interface; the long quiz is the main hurdle
• OurTime: simpler and more traditional; very friendly if you’re new to dating sites

Neither requires tech skills. OurTime is slightly easier on day one; SilverSingles feels more premium.

Safety and Profile Quality

• SilverSingles manually verifies profiles and uses fraud detection – fake accounts are relatively rare
• OurTime verifies too, but its open-browsing model means you’ll occasionally spot low-effort or inactive profiles

Both let you block and report users. As always, keep first meetings in public places.

SilverSingles Pros and Cons

Pros:

• High-quality curated matches
• Strong profile verification
• Compatibility-based, not just photos
• Clean, ad-free experience

Cons:

• Long signup quiz
• Limited number of daily matches
• No free messaging

OurTime Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Largest 50+ dating pool in the US
• Free browsing before you pay
• Fast, simple signup
• Backed by Match Group

Cons:

• Match quality varies more
• Messaging is paywalled
• Interface feels dated
• Coin/promo upsells

Who Should Pick SilverSingles?

• You’re happy to answer a questionnaire and let the algorithm work
• You prefer quality over quantity
• You value verified, serious profiles

Who Should Pick OurTime?

• You want the biggest possible pool, especially outside big cities
• You like browsing and searching yourself
• You want the fastest, simplest start

The Bottom Line

You can’t really lose – both are the top two options in 50+ dating:

• Want guided, compatibility-based matching? → SilverSingles
• Want control, volume and simplicity? → OurTime

And since both are cheap on 12-month plans, some people genuinely try both for a month before committing.

FAQ

Is SilverSingles or OurTime better for serious relationships?
Both serve serious daters. SilverSingles’ matching system is more compatibility-driven; OurTime gives you more people to choose from.

Which is cheaper?
Essentially identical on 12-month plans (~$20/month). Short plans cost more on both. Check current promotions.

Can I use either for free?
Both offer free signup and browsing. Messaging requires a paid plan on both.

Which has more fake profiles?
Both verify profiles, but SilverSingles’ curated model keeps quality higher. OurTime’s larger, open pool means more variance.

Can I use both at the same time?
Yes – many over-50 singles do exactly that for the first month, then keep the one that fits them better.